Shifting from

“Influencers” to “Creators”

Most “influencers” aren’t really influencers anymore. They’re creative directors, editors, videographers and storytellers, but the industry is still using language from 2015.

In this article, Talent Agent Sarah McAleer unpacks why the industry needs to update their wording and language when it comes to creators.

The term influencer comes from the early days of social media marketing. Back then, brands were primarily paying for access to an audience. The value was reach, visibility, and the perceived ability of someone to influence their followers’ purchasing decisions.

The model was simple: A brand partnered with someone with a large following, paid for a post, and hoped that exposure would translate into sales.

But the landscape has evolved dramatically since then.

Today, many of the people brands work with aren’t just promoting products,  they’re creating content ecosystems. They’re developing concepts, telling stories, producing high-quality video, understanding platform trends, and building communities around their work.

In other words, they’re not just influencing. They’re creating, and that distinction matters more than it might seem!

The best creators today operate more like creative partners or boutique production studios. They write scripts, shoot and edit, understand the algorithm and know exactly how to make content feel native to a platform. Many of them can produce work that performs better than traditional advertising, because they understand their audience and the platform they’re creating for.

Yet the industry language hasn’t quite caught up. When brands think about someone as an influencer, the collaboration often becomes transactional. The brief might follow the format of:

Post about our product.
Include these talking points.
Mention this feature.

But when brands approach someone as a creator, the dynamic shifts.

The conversation becomes less about posting and more about what we can build together. Instead of asking someone to simply promote a product, brands start thinking about how that product can become part of a compelling piece of content. That shift transforms the relationship. It moves collaborations from:

  • Transactional → Creative

  • One-off campaigns → Long-term partnerships

  • Distribution-first → Storytelling-first

And ultimately, it leads to better outcomes for everyone involved.

Of course, the terms creator and influencer are often used interchangeably today, and many people in the industry identify with both. But the growing shift toward the word creator reflects something deeper about where the industry is heading.

The future of this space isn’t about renting someone’s audience for a post. It’s about collaborating with talented storytellers who know how to capture attention and build culture online.

Maybe it’s time our language caught up with that reality; less influencer marketing and more creator collaboration!

Get in touch with us for more information- hello@collabagency.com

Next
Next

The Rise of Community-First Creators