The Forgotten Deliverable: The Creator’s Comment Section

When we talk about the success of a creator campaign, we tend to focus on the content itself.

Was the content engaging? Did it reach the right audience? How many views did it get? What was the engagement rate?

But there’s another part of the campaign sitting directly underneath the content that can sometimes be overlooked: the comment section.

In this article, Talent Agent Sarah McAleer, explores the true value of a creator’s comment section in branded campaigns.

A creator’s comment section isn’t just a collection of engagement metrics, it’s where their community reacts, asks questions, shares opinions and, importantly for brands, talks about the product.

And when a brand partners with a creator, they’re entering that conversation too.

The comments can tell you more than the likes!

A like is great, but it doesn’t necessarily tell you why someone engaged.

The comments can.

“Where can I get this?”

“Is this available in Ireland?”

“I’ve been looking for something like this.”

“I actually use this already and love it.”

Or even simply tagging a friend who they know would be interested.

These are valuable signals that can easily get lost when campaign performance is reduced to views, likes and an overall engagement rate.

Sometimes, a smaller piece of content with a highly engaged and relevant comment section can tell a brand far more than a post with significantly higher reach but very little conversation.

Brands should be ready to join in.

Once the content goes live, there’s an opportunity for the brand to become part of that conversation.

If someone asks where they can purchase the product, the brand can answer. If there’s a question about a particular feature, ingredient or service, they can provide the information. If someone shares a positive experience, they can acknowledge it.

It sounds simple, but having the brand actively present in the comments can make a creator partnership feel much more connected, and makes the audience feel involved!

This is particularly important during the first few hours after posting, when the creator is likely to be engaging with their audience and conversation around the content is at its most active.

But what about the difficult comments?

Not every comment section will be completely positive and that shouldn’t necessarily be viewed as a problem.

Certain products, industries and campaign topics naturally generate more questions, opinions or criticism than others. The important thing is that the creator shouldn’t be left to figure out how to handle those conversations alone.

Before content goes live, brands and agencies should consider the obvious questions that might come up.

Are there FAQs the creator should have? Is there particular wording they should use or avoid? Which questions can the creator comfortably answer themselves, and which should be left to the brand? And if a genuinely negative or sensitive comment appears, who is responsible for responding?

This becomes even more important when a creator is fronting a campaign around a topic that their audience may have strong opinions on.

You can read more about how brands can support creators in trickier situations in our article “Has The Brand Got Your Back?”

Creators know their comment sections best.

There is also a balance to strike. A creator has spent years developing their own tone and relationship with their audience. Suddenly dropping highly corporate responses into their comment section can feel out of place, so the creator should still be able to respond as themselves.

Brands can provide the facts and guidance they need, but the creator understands how their audience communicates. In many cases, a natural response from the creator will land far better than a pre-approved paragraph copied directly from a brand FAQ.

Start treating comments as part of the campaign!

The creator’s job doesn’t necessarily end when they press “post”, and neither should the brand’s.

When planning a creator campaign, we should be thinking about what happens underneath the content as well as what appears in it.

That means giving creators the information they need to answer questions, having a plan for negative or sensitive responses, encouraging the brand to engage where appropriate and paying attention to the quality of the conversation when reporting on campaign performance.

Because when a brand partners with a creator, they’re not only getting access to their content, they’re being invited into their community and the comment section is often where that community comes to life.

Get in touch with us for more information on creator marketing- hello@collabagency.com

Next
Next

The Creator Is the Company